Remember, remember

-

Today is, of course, November the 5th, Guy Fawkes Night. This means there's really only Graphic Novel I can write about in here: Alan Moore's V for Vendetta. However, rather than attempting to review a piece of work which I feel I do not yet fully understand(I've only read it twice) I thought I would talk in broader terms about it's creator.
Alan Moore is an author I sometimes fail to understand. Clearly his work is amazing and has changed the landscape for comic book writers forever, one only has to read Watchmen to see that, and when watching any of the many interviews with him over the years it's clear that he has great passion for his work but, at the same time, he also seems to have a burning hatred for any form of adaptation of his work. This baffles me.
Don't get me wrong, there are some parts of his argument I wholly agree with. Trying to create spin-offs from stories which have a definitive ending for example, is ridiculous and without out a doubt shows contempt for the original work, but I've always considered film adaptations to be a different matter. Admittedly, Moore has every right to be sceptical of this point. The first big screen version of one of his works, 2003's League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, was nothing short of a train wreck which had almost nothing in common with its source material. However, both the subsequent adaptions of his other works, V for Vendetta and Watchmen, were both excellent films in their own right, with the latter being one the best comic book adaptations I have ever seen.
Despite this, Moore continues to treat anything other than his own work with contempt, refusing to have his name on any film versions. To me this feels a lot like sulking, refusing to acknowledge the hard work of others because it doesn't fit your perfect vision and to me that seems wrong. After all, you don't see McCartney standing up and saying: "I hereby band all Beatles covers!" do you?
I understand being protective of your work, I am too, but once something has been published it's out there influenceing people...Maybe it's better to let go?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Werid Leicester: An outlaw legacy

-
I like Sons of Anarchy. That is not a particularly controversial statement, in the seven years that the show was on television it garnered a sizeable following and it's easy to see why: the show's narrative is pure crime fiction of the most enjoyable kind. The assorted characters that inhabit the titular outlaw motorcycle club are the friendly, likeable, family orientated face of the criminal underworld, in a world full of bad guys, they are the least bad. As you might imagine, the show trades heavily on the mythic status of real outlaw clubs such as the Hells Angels. The more I watched the show, having always had a certain fascination with the world's criminal subcultures, I found myself drawn towards researching the real crimes, exploits and history of outlaw motorcycle clubs, specifically within the UK and the part of it I call home: the city of Leicester. At first I didn't think I would find anything. Like most midlands cities, Leicester has suffered in our post ind
Read more

It's all about image

-
Image
I first came across the world of Image comics though an unlikely source: Tomb Raider. Sometime in 1998, during the height of the original game trilogy's popularity, I picked up an issue of Image's Tomb Raider/Witchblade crossover series. Although initially more interested in Lara croft's side of the story, I quickly latched to the character of Sara Pezzini and her symbiotic weapon the witchblade and found myself intrigued by it's powers as well as the universe it inhabited. The Witchblade series, with it's action-packed storylines and varied and brutal backstory, fired my imagination and I soon found myself hungry for more. It was then that I found myself moving towards Witchblade's sister series, The Darkness. I have written about The Darkness on this blog before, and what I said then still holds true today: It is by far one of the most interesting comic series ever created. The darkness(and it's wielder Jackie Estacardo) are, to my mind, almost the per
Read more

Kick Ass is...Well, kick ass!

-
Image
Last week I went out to the cinema and was treated to what I consider to be the first genuinely enjoyable Hollywood adaptation of a comic book since Watchmen: Kick Ass. Like every other comic book devotee, this movie was no suprise to me. Almost as soon as it was first published by Marvel in 2008, it was clear that Mark Millar's story of a comic book nerd who gets to live out his fantasies was crying out to be turned into a script. As ever, I was cynical. Kick Ass' central brilliance stems from it's ability to poke fun at it's audience: "If you've ever thought about becoming a superhero, this is how badly you'd fail" it says without ever forgetting that, at it's heart, it's still a comic book movie. The film manages to balance humour and action more successfully in it's attempt to parody the genre than many straight comic book movies. For me, films like this seem to signalling a change in the way Hollywood sees comic books, something
Read more